Owls/logging/fire debate in ongoing “collaboration” in Arizona

This story seems to deal with some substantive and procedural questions that are popular on this blog.  Environmental groups are offering alternatives that the Forest Service doesn’t seem interested in. Elson, the Flagstaff District Ranger, acknowledged that some parts of the FWPP plan do fly in the face of the Mexican spotted owl recovery plan’s …

Continue reading ‘Owls/logging/fire debate in ongoing “collaboration” in Arizona’ »

Participating, Objecting and Litigating: AWR and Some Montana Projects

A reader sent me this series of questions about AWR’s objections to some Montana projects: It would appear the Alliance for the Wild Rockies isn’t participating in the formal public comment piece of the proceedings. The attached are objection responses for the East Reservoir (Kootenai) and Trapper Creek (BDNF) projects in Montana. Dated 7/17/14 and …

Continue reading ‘Participating, Objecting and Litigating: AWR and Some Montana Projects’ »

Collaborative objections?

This is apparently the first test of the 2012 planning rule objection process for forest plan revisions (though the plans were prepared under the 1982 rule).  On the Kootenai, there were 38 objectors and the same number of ‘interested persons’ (presumably some overlap).  On the Idaho Panhandle, 22 objectors and 94 interested persons.  Someone distilled …

Continue reading ‘Collaborative objections?’ »

News Story on Objections.. Missoulian

Thanks to Rob Chaney for writing a story on this.. there’s been a great deal of silence out there in Medialand on this. Here’s a link.. Western Environmental Law attorney and Lewis and Clark Law School professor Susan Jane Brown has served on a federal advisory board reviewing the new Forest Service rules. She said …

Continue reading ‘News Story on Objections.. Missoulian’ »

Objections Rule and Press Release

Forest Service rule governing predecisional objection process published Provides for public input prior to decision-making for many projects and activities WASHINGTON, March 26, 2013 – The U.S. Forest Service today announced the final rule governing the objection process for projects and activities implementing land-management plans. The final rule will be published in the Federal Register …

Continue reading ‘Objections Rule and Press Release’ »

More Info Dribbling Out From Lewiston About Objections Rule

AP story here. My favorite part of this story was… But critics worry the changes will force them to predict the future. Instead of filing an appeal based on a specific decision, they will have to anticipate a wide range of possible final decisions the agency might make. “Whether you are a timber industry advocate …

Continue reading ‘More Info Dribbling Out From Lewiston About Objections Rule’ »

Objections Rule to Be Released (?) and a Recap on “Contacting Your Representatives”

This came across me email from the LM Tribune online here. The U.S. Forest Service is changing the process by which citizens can challenge timber sales and other actions. Under the new guidelines, which are expected to be unveiled this week, people who want to challenge agency actions will be required to fully participate in …

Continue reading ‘Objections Rule to Be Released (?) and a Recap on “Contacting Your Representatives”’ »

Sharon’s Easy Guide to the Proposed Objections Rule

Some folks thought it was difficult to understand the bureacratese of this proposed reg. So I scheduled 2 hours to develop an “easy guide”. It only took an hour and a half, and now it will take you less, and you will get more out of it. An objections rule describes a process, so most …

Continue reading ‘Sharon’s Easy Guide to the Proposed Objections Rule’ »

Draft Objection Process in Federal Register- Beginning of 30 Day Comment Period

Here’s a link from the FS website. US Forest Service proposes to streamline land management plan review process Provides for public comment opportunity for some land management plans WASHINGTON, Aug. 8, 2012 — The U.S. Forest Service today published in the Federal Register a proposed regulation that will improve the administrative review process for proposed …

Continue reading ‘Draft Objection Process in Federal Register- Beginning of 30 Day Comment Period’ »

A Tale of Three Projects – South Shore Fuel Reduction

An interesting thing that happens on this blog is that we get “into the weeds” or snags (?) of projects in different parts of the country, so we can compare the different approaches and concerns. We also have readers with on-the-ground experience in many of these areas. Thanks to Derek for submitting these articles about …

Continue reading ‘A Tale of Three Projects – South Shore Fuel Reduction’ »