Federal judge reinstates 21-inch rule east of the Cascades

Thanks (again!) to Nick Smith for this link…. It’s an Oregon Public Broadcasting article from April 2 on the eastside screens, which we’ve discussed several times, such as here and here.

Federal judge finalizes protections for large trees east of the Cascades

A federal judge has finalized the return of national forest protections for large trees growing east of the Cascades.

The order brings back protections that had long prohibited logging trees larger than 21 inches in diameter from six national forests in eastern Oregon and Washington.

During the final days of the Trump Administration, the U.S. Forest Service amended its guidelines known as Eastside Screens. The amendment removed the agency’s 21-inch standard that had protected large trees across 8 million acres of forestland since 1994.

The agency at the time determined the change wouldn’t significantly impact the environment, and it bypassed procedures that would typically give the public opportunities to comment. The Forest Service claimed this sudden change was needed to thin forests and prevent major wildfires.

Six conservation groups sued the agency in 2022, arguing the policy change violated national forest and species protections laws. The following year, U.S. Magistrate Judge Andrew Hallman recommended the Forest Service restore the large tree protections, calling the agency’s decisions “arbitrary and capricious.” But his recommendations needed final approval from a U.S. district court judge.

On Friday, District Judge Ann Aiken issued an order agreeing with Hallman. Aiken concluded the Forest Service violated several federal laws and “failed to take a hard look at the amendment’s change and its impact on aquatic species.”

Aiken’s order calls on the Forest Service to prepare an environmental impact statement, which is required when a new policy could harm the environment. That process also requires the agency to collect public comments.

The Forest Service did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Conservation groups applauded Aiken’s decision, calling it a win for eastside forests where just 3% of trees are larger than 21 inches in diameter.

The nonprofit Greater Hells Canyon Council was among them.

“The amount of trees that this actually applies to is very few,” conservation director Jamie Dawson said. “So it’s very important that they stay standing and are providing that wildlife habitat value: Storing carbon dioxide, cleaning pollution from the air, influencing the water cycle, cleaning our drinking water, all of the stuff that large and old trees do.”

Two Projects, One Litigated

Two stories about forest management in SW Oregon.

Helicopter logging project to begin in Ashland watershed and Siskiyou Mountain Park

Background on Ashland’s Forestland Climate Adaptation Project in its city watershed:

The first phase of work to help forests transition and adapt to the changing climate is reducing wildfire fuels that threaten our community and the forest’s ecological integrity. Phase 1 will utilize a helicopter to remove dead, dying, and crowded trees from Siskiyou Mountain Park and City-owned land in the lower Ashland Watershed. Helicopters have been used extensively in the Ashland Watershed over the past 20 years due to their low impact on resources. Phase II, expected to last several years, will involve replanting with species adapted to drought, heat, and frequent fire, along with ongoing use of prescribed fire for wildfire safety and ecosystem benefit. 

IMHO, Ashland is being very proactive — a great example for other communities.

The Klamath-Siskiyou Wildlands Center objects and plans a rally outside the courthouse next week:

“Integrated Vegetation Management” Is Not What It Sounds Like

It sure sounds benign, doesn’t it? The words “integrated vegetation management” evoke visions of thoughtful fuel reduction efforts designed to restore and protect public forests and surrounding communities. There’s no doubt the name was chosen for a reason. Unfortunately, BLM timber planners are using their new Integrated Vegetation Management (IVM) project to target old-growth forests within Late Successional Reserves for conversion into “open seral” stump-fields devoid of trees.

The other project is on BLM land in neighboring Josephine County.

Three conservation groups challenging BLM forest plan in Medford federal court

BLM Late Mungers project info:

Why is the BLM conducting commercial treatments in Late Successional Reserves?

Fifty-one percent of all forests in southwest Oregon are overly dense and our area has the highest need for restoration, via thinning and prescribed fire, in all of Oregon and Washington. The Southwest Oregon Resource Management Plan identifies active management objectives for Late Successional Reserves (LSR), including commercial thinning/group selection harvest on 17,000 acres in LSR per decade. These commercial treatments are designated to develop, maintain, or promote northern spotted owl (Strix occidentalis caurina) nesting-roosting habitat. In addition, the BLM manages LSRs to: 1) enable forests to recover from past management measures, 2) respond to climate-driven stresses, wildfire and other disturbance events, 3) ensure positive or neutral ecological impacts from wildfire, and 4) contribute to northern spotted owl recovery.

How is BLM protecting large, fire resilient trees in the Late Mungers Project Area?

Late Mungers is designed to protect and culture large, old trees. The project protects large trees by removing adjacent trees and fuels. Clumps of fire tolerant legacy trees would be retained. Conifer trees (pine [Pinus spp.] and Douglas fir [Pseudotsuga menziesii] greater than or equal to 36-inches DBH) and hardwoods greater than 24-inches DBH would be retained. In non-conifer plant communities, large conifers and hardwoods (often greater than 24-inches DBH) would be retained. Thinning also creates growing space for the next generation of legacy trees.

NW Forest Plan Advisory Committee Meeting, April 16-18, Weaverville, CA 

FYI, plan watchers….

Northwest Forest Plan Federal Advisory Committee’s  Next MeetingApril 16-18 in Weaverville, California 

PORTLAND, Ore. (Mar. 26, 2024) – The Northwest Forest Plan Area Federal Advisory Committee (FAC) will meet April 16-18 at the Redding Rancheria Trinity Health Center, 81 Arbuckle Court, Weaverville, California. This will be the fourth meeting for the Federal Advisory Committee to provide the Forest Service with recommended updates for the Northwest Forest Plan Amendment.     

The Secretary of Agriculture established this committee to support ongoing efforts to amend the Northwest Forest Plan. The Federal Advisory Committee brings together representatives with diverse perspectives, experiences and expertise — including community, tribal, government and other interest groups from across the Northwest Forest Plan landscape to inform the plan amendment.  

This group is helping the agency identify ways to effectively conserve key resources while considering social, ecological, and economic conditions and needs.  

FAC meetings are open to the public with an opportunity to submit comments. Details on meetings, including how the public can provide information to the committee is posted on the regional website: https://www.fs.usda.gov/detail/r6/landmanagement/planning/?cid=fseprd1076013.

The Federal Advisory Committee does not replace the public involvement process or the public’s opportunity to engage directly with the Forest Service regarding Northwest Forest Plan amendment efforts during the planning process.  

The Northwest Forest Plan covers 24.5 million acres of federally managed lands in northwestern California, western Oregon, and Washington. It was established in 1994 to address threats to threatened and endangered species while also contributing to social and economic sustainability in the region. After nearly 30 years, the Northwest Forest Plan needs updated to accommodate changed ecological and social conditions.  

Additional information about the Northwest Forest Plan: www.fs.usda.gov/detail/r6/landmanagement/planning/?cid=fsbdev2_026990

Federal Register Notice: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/

For more about USDA Forest Service, visit https://www.fs.usda.gov/r6.

Paper: Fire suppression makes wildfires more severe

Open-access paper in Nature Communications, “Fire suppression makes wildfires more severe and accentuates impacts of climate change and fuel accumulation.”

Abstract:

Fire suppression is the primary management response to wildfires in many areas globally. By removing less-extreme wildfires, this approach ensures that remaining wildfires burn under more extreme conditions. Here, we term this the “suppression bias” and use a simulation model to highlight how this bias fundamentally impacts wildfire activity, independent of fuel accumulation and climate change. We illustrate how attempting to suppress all wildfires necessarily means that fires will burn with more severe and less diverse ecological impacts, with burned area increasing at faster rates than expected from fuel accumulation or climate change. Over a human lifespan, the modeled impacts of the suppression bias exceed those from fuel accumulation or climate change alone, suggesting that suppression may exert a significant and underappreciated influence on patterns of fire globally. Managing wildfires to safely burn under low and moderate conditions is thus a critical tool to address the growing wildfire crisis.

Thanks, Nick Smith, for adding this to your Healthy Forests news roundup today….

New Wild Turkey Federation Agreement with USFS

Apologies if someone posted about this already…. Link is here.

Amidst the increasing threat of wildfires, the USDA Forest Service has taken a proactive stance by implementing the comprehensive 10-year Wildfire Crisis Strategy designed to confront the crisis in areas posing the most immediate threats to communities. The NWTF, with a longstanding history of partnering with the Forest Service on stewardship projects nationwide, recognizes the urgency of addressing western landscape issues and fully supports the Wildfire Crisis Strategy.

The Participating Agreement enables the NWTF to enhance its support for this critical initiative by providing funding for new positions dedicated to supporting the implementation of the Master Stewardship Agreement. Funding for this agreement comes entirely from federal dollars authorized in the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law and the Inflation Reduction Act. This includes covering expenses such as personnel costs, including travel, and supporting essential meetings like Partner Coordination Meetings and Industry Coordination Meetings to foster effective communication and collaboration among stakeholders.

Currently, the NWTF has two key staff positions dedicated to implementing the Master Stewardship Agreement under the Wildfire Crisis Strategy, a Wildfire Crisis Manager and a Regional Wildfire Crisis Coordinator.

 

Homes Lost to Wildfire: It’s the Grass

CNN story:

Over the last three decades, the number of US homes destroyed by wildfire has more than doubled as fires burn bigger and badder, a recent study found. Most of those homes were burned not by forest fires, but by fires racing through grass and shrubs.

The West is most at risk, the study found, where more than two-thirds of the homes burned over the last 30 years were located. Of those, nearly 80% were burned in grass and shrub fires.

Old Growth: How Much is Enough? — 4 Responses

Back in November,  I posted “Old Growth: How Much is Enough?” with a link to the Dovetail Partners report of the same title. (Only 2 comments on TSW.)

Now Dovetail has posted 4 “guest responses” to the report. The group explains:

In November 2023, Dovetail Partners released a report titled, “Old growth forests: How much is enough?”. In the report, we explored the different definitions of “old growth” applied globally and in regions of North America and Europe, including their scientific basis. The report considered why we need old growth forests, and conversely, why we do not, and included a discussion of old growth forest protection and management. We concluded with a discussion how much old growth is ‘enough’, how we can create more, and how our understanding of the relationship between people and forests is evolving.

We asked the following individuals to respond to the report, “Old growth forests: How much is enough?”, and compiled their feedback into one document.

Marcella Windmuller-Campione
Marcella is an Associate Professor with the Department of Forest Resources at the University of Minnesota.

Dr. Alexander Evans, Forest Stewards Guild
As an Executive Director, Zander focuses on building partnerships, promoting sound policy, and supporting on-the-ground implementation of ecological forestry. He has a PhD from the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies and worked as a cartographer and spatial analyst with the US Geological Survey.

Dave Atkins
Dave is a Family Forest Owner and President of the Montana Forest Owners Association; he is one of the authors of the Mass Timber Report.

Joseph Vaughn, CF
Joseph is a Key Account Manager at NCX and has a deep rooted passion for sustainable forest management.

Outdoor Life Magazine Looks at MOG

Nick Smith has this in his Healthy Forests, Healthy Communities email today. Interesting that it’s from Outdoor Life, which says it “has been the go-to publication of America’s diehard hunters, shooters, and anglers since 1898. Our stories are written by hunters, for hunters. We value experience in the field, at the range, and on the water above all else. Our mission is to deliver stories about success in the field, cutting-edge gear, and adventures in far-off wildernesses and close-to-home woodlots. We inspire America’s outdoorsmen and women to chase the critters they’re passionate about and fight for the wild places they love.”

Here’s Why No One Can Agree on How to Manage America’s Old Growth Forests

The Biden administration’s plan to climate-proof old growth and mature forests generates mixed opinions from the conservation community

PNW Forest Plan Revision Update and LSR Trends

The USFS press release today: “The initial comment period for the USDA Forest Service’s Northwest Forest Plan concluded Feb. 2. The Forest Service had been accepting comments on a Notice of Intent that the Agency will prepare an Environmental Impact Statement to evaluate the effects of proposed amendments to the Northwest Forest Plan.” Info here.

There’s an interesting Powerpoint presentation here, “Information Winter Webinar, January 2024.” Lots of stats and trends. This slide, for example, on LSR trends. Steady until recent wildfires.

This is compelling evidence that simply setting aside older forests with little or no active management is a losing proposition.

 

Horses, Mules Still Vital to Forest Service Meeting its Mission and the Rocky Mountain Region Horse Whisperer

crosby davidson
Elaine Collins/Special to The Daily Sentine lCrosby Davidson with the Shoshone Specialty Pack String is shown on a pack trip into the Eagles Nest Wilderness in Colorado in 2022 with materials for a bridge.
Interesting article from the Grand Junction Sentinel

U.S. Forest Service employees who gathered for a training in Rifle earlier this month weren’t there to learn about how to make use of newfangled things such as drones or artificial intelligence to do their jobs.

Rather, they were learning more about a resource that was vital to the Forest Service getting work done even in its early days and remains important today. And there to lead the lesson was Crosby Davidson, appropriately attired in chaps, boots and a cowboy hat.

“We affectionately call Crosby the horse whisperer for the Rocky Mountain Region” of the Forest Service, said Scott Woodall, lead rangeland ecologist for the White River National Forest.

Davidson is the lead packer for what’s called the Shoshone Specialty Pack String, a team of horses, mules and packers based out of the Shoshone National Forest in Wyoming. By virtue of its high level of experience and expertise, the team serves as a regional resource for the Forest Service when it comes to both higher-demand forest packing projects and training in the skills of horsemanship and packing.

In Rifle, Davidson was leading horsemanship instruction for employees from various parts of the White River National Forest with a range of experience, or lack thereof, in the subject.

He said that traveling around the Forest Service’s Rocky Mountain region, he occasionally runs into people who are surprised and interested to learn that the Forest Service has always had a pretty robust horse program, especially in areas with large areas of wilderness or roadless areas where vehicle access can’t be used to get materials and people into them.

“People seem pretty excited sometimes when we pull into the trail head and explain it to them,” Davidson said.

Woodall, whose job includes managing what the White River National Forest calls its livestock program, said 55% of the forest’s 2.3 million is wilderness or roadless acreage.

“Our livestock is the main means of transportation into our high country,” he said.

He said the program currently consists of 15 horses and mules, with animals based out of Rifle, Meeker and Eagle County. The animals can be used for carrying in materials for things such as trail, bridge and fencing projects, and for ferrying out old materials, as well as other things such as trash left behind by forest visitors.

Woodall said the animals are valuable in helping agency ecologists, biologists, foresters and other scientists and specialists access the high country more easily than on foot, while also bringing along all the tools, equipment, food and other supplies they might need for perhaps a week-long trip.

“The first thing in land resource management is getting to where you need to go to see the land,” he said.

He said scientists need to do things such as dig into soils, examine plants and insects up close, and sometimes even employ senses of touch, smell and taste to do their jobs, and using something like a drone can’t replace being there in person.

“I don’t think anything will ever take the place of actually being on the ground,” he said.

But it’s also important to get there and back safely, which is a major reason for providing horsemanship training and certification for employees. During the three-day class at the Garfield County Fairgrounds, Davidson and a second instructor led students through fundamentals of saddling and bridling horses, and the basics of riding them, steering them, getting them to speed up and slow down, and so on.

“It’s a lifetime of learning,” Davidson said. “You can’t get it done in three days, but you can get the building blocks started.”

Davidson has spent a lifetime himself being around horses and learning from them. As a youth he packed with his parents into the Wind River Range in Wyoming for their outfitting business. He started packing as a seasonal employee for the Forest Service right after high school and got his first permanent job on the Shoshone forest as a trail crew foreman, doing a lot of packing to get materials on-site. He has had his current job for several years.

“I can’t get enough of horses and mules, so I’ll tolerate the trail work in order to be able to be around horses and mules. I don’t like swinging a pick quite as much as I like riding a horse but they’re both really good jobs and just being in the woods is really nice,” he said.

As he spoke, he occasionally stroked the head of one of his team’s horses named Slim, while Slim occasionally champed at a bit the horse was still getting used to.

“I really like Slim. Slim’s very curious. He’s very willing. He’s always willing to try to get the job done,” Davidson said. “He’s always searching for the right answer. He’s the kind you want; he’s one of the good ones for sure.”

He said other horses can be harder to communicate with, but all horses have their strengths and weaknesses.

“That’s the fun part, is when you get to something that’s challenging you, you’re really having a hard time communicating with your horse and getting your point across to them, it’s usually the horse that teaches you how to get through that,” Davidson said.

He said he loves participating in trainings because no matter how long he’s been doing them, there’s always something to learn from other people and the horses.

“My hope is that some folks will take stuff away from this but I know for a fact that I will,” he said. “I always do. I always learn something.”

He said that while he spends the winter and spring teaching, when the snow is melted the Shoshone Specialty Pack String keeps busy traveling around the Forest Service Rocky Mountain Region doing projects. It fills in in areas where the Forest Service doesn’t have a local stock program, or for larger projects, which can involve things such as blasting or bringing in larger materials for things such as bridge construction.

As one example, the Shoshone outfits’ mules are more used to safely packing long timbers than often is the case for other animals.

“We can pack 8- to 10-foot timbers, which is kind of a scary thing for a horse or mule to do for the first time,” he said.

Woodall said the Shoshone pack string is scheduled to carry a big load out of the Flat Tops this summer; he said he thinks the load will involve old fencing. He said some local forest employees also will be there to learn from the experience.

Leeann Veldhuis, district ranger for the Eagle-Holy Cross Ranger District, participated in the recent training and said her previous experience riding horses was limited to a couple of tourist-type rides while on family trips as she was growing up. She appreciated the fundamentals she learned in Rifle.

“I’ve learned a ton. A lot of it is understanding the horse and the horse’s mentality and how I as the person have to approach the horse and interact with the horse to get him or her to do what I’m looking for them to do,” she said. “They’re another living creature and it requires a communication style that we’re not used to because they’re an animal.”

Veldhuis views the ability to ride a horse as helpful in being able to get out with her range permit administrator to meet grazing permit holders in range allotments that just in her district cover about 450,000 acres, some of it in wilderness.

“That’s obviously a lot of ground to cover and learn about, and understand what’s happening out there on the ground,” she said.

She appreciated the opportunity to learn from experts from the Shoshone pack string.

“It’s been a really unique and I think meaningful experience for all the staff here who got to participate in one of the oldest Forest Service activities that there is,” Veldhuis said.

“Horsemanship, horse riding — it’s been here since the beginning.”

**********
Please feel free to add your own FS horse or mule stories below, or email them and I will post on Story Saturdays.